Did you have the time when you spelled like “goed” or “comed” as past tense forms of the verbs instead of spelling “went” or “came” when you were a child? #1971

  •  
  • 154
  • 12
  • 6
  • English 
Oct 6, 2017 21:14 Japanese language fact
I read an explanation about “U-shaped development” in Japanese today.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U-shaped_development 

According to it, native English speakers spelled correctly past tense forms of the irregular verbs when they were children first. However, when they studied the rule of how to form the past tense form of the regular verbs, they temporarily misspell the irregular verbs with applying the rule for regular verbs by adding “ed,” such as “goed”, “ccomed”, etc.

Also, the U-shaped curve can be seen amongst the second language learners. Although they were able to use the second language correctly, when they learn new rules, they temporarily cannot use the second language as they used to be.

Have you experienced the situation of the bottom of U-shaped curve? ^^
今日、日本語で「U字型発達」についての説明を読みました。

それによると、英語の母語話者は子供の頃、最初は不規則動詞を正しく綴ることができるのですが、規則動詞の作り方の規則を学ぶと、一時的ですが、それまで正しく綴れていた不規則動詞にも規則動詞の過去形の作り方を適用して、「ed」を付けてしまい、「goed」や「comed」と綴りの間違いをする時期があるらしいです。

このU字型発達は、第二言語を学ぶ人にもみられ、それまで第二言語を正しく使えていた人が、新しい規則を学ぶと、一時的に今まで正しく使えていた第二言語が正しく使えなくなる事があるらしいです。

皆さんは、U字の底辺(間違いをしてしまう)状態を経験したことがありますか?

Learn English, Spanish, and other languages for free with the HiNative app